Connect with Helen:
John Anthony Miller
John Anthony Miller writes all things historical—thrillers, mysteries, and romance. He sets his novels in exotic locations spanning all eras of space and time, with complex characters forced to face inner conflicts—fighting demons both real and imagined. He’s published twenty novels and ghostwritten several others, including Another Soul Saved. He lives in southern New Jersey.
Recommended for readers who enjoy An American Beauty by Shana Abé and When the World Fell Silent by Donna Jones Alward.
Three hearts. Lost love. One impossible choice.
A character-driven historical saga featuring the love triangle of a seaman, a governess and a wealthy speculator. Told through letters, the sweep of 19th century events like the gold rush, whaling voyages, and the streets of Manhattan unfold.
At the height of the 1840s whaling era, Catherine McGuirk arrives in Sag Harbor, New York. She has already spurned a marriage proposal from Patrick Lynch on her passage from Ireland and is confident she will find work as a governess, or at least a teacher. The local schoolmaster dismisses her with a smirk. Settling for hotel work has its upside when Cath meets a handsome seaman, Michael Heffernan. Just as she falls in love, he is off on a whaling voyage.
Spending her romance alone spurs Cath to continue her correspondence with Patrick. His ascent as a successful businessman in New York is swift, while Michael promises to give up the sea for marriage to Cath. Yet, when the Gold rush calls, he cannot resist.
A brokenhearted Cath moves to New York to revive her dream of becoming a governess. Once in Manhattan, she continues to be torn between her own ambition, her missing husband, and her former beau.
When The Stones Held is an unforgettable historical novel inspired by the true story of William Edwards, the self taught Welsh stonemason who built one of the greatest bridges of the eighteenth century.
Born into poverty in the remote valleys of South Wales, William grows up in a world shaped by hard labour, dangerous rivers, and communities struggling to survive. Education is rare. Opportunity is rarer still. Yet from childhood, William becomes fascinated by stone, by balance, and by the dream of building something that will outlive him.
As the coal trade begins transforming Wales and merchants demand safer routes through the valleys, William sets himself an impossible task, to build a bridge across the fierce River Taff where others have failed. Floods destroy his work. Rivals mock him. Powerful men try to break him. Each collapse threatens his reputation, his livelihood, and the people he loves.
Set against the harsh beauty of eighteenth century Wales, When The Stones Held is a story of ambition, resilience, love, grief, and determination. It brings to life the people, language, and struggles of a forgotten world while telling the remarkable true story behind the bridge that gave birth to the town of Pontypridd.
Perfect for readers who enjoy rich historical fiction, Welsh history, and stories of ordinary people achieving extraordinary things.
There are some protagonists who stride onto the page looking terribly important and practically demand that you pay attention to them.
William Edwards is not one of those protagonists.
When we first meet him, he is six years old, living with his family in the Welsh valleys, listening to the rain, watching his father work and drawing structures on a slate that, frankly, have a fairly good chance of falling on somebody's foot. But William has something that cannot really be taught: he wants to understand why things stand and, perhaps more importantly, why they fall.
And that, as it turns out, is going to matter.
'When the Stones Held' by David Owen is a wonderfully absorbing historical novel inspired by the life of William Edwards, the eighteenth-century Welsh stonemason and bridge builder. I knew nothing about Edwards before picking up this novel, and I suspect many readers will be in the same position. By the end, however, I was completely invested in this quiet, determined man and his seemingly impossible ambition to make stone do what he believed it could.
What I particularly enjoyed was that Owen does not rush William towards greatness. We are allowed to know him first as a boy. We see his family, his home, his community and the landscape that shapes him. We watch him learn through observation, work and, rather satisfyingly, failure.
Lots of failure.
Poor William spends a considerable amount of time discovering that stones are remarkably unforgiving things. They do not care how enthusiastic you are. They do not care how long you have been staring at them. And they certainly do not stay where you put them merely because you would very much like them to.
Fortunately, William is stubborn.
His relationship with Morgan was one of my favourite elements of the novel. Morgan understands that simply giving William answers would teach him very little. Instead, he makes him think. William has to look at the river, consider the weight of the stone, understand the force of the water and work out where the pressure will go. Morgan allows him to get things wrong because getting them wrong is part of becoming the man he will eventually be.
There is a lovely moment when William admits that everything he has tried has fallen down. Morgan's response is essentially that this is excellent news because now he might actually be ready to learn.
I liked Morgan enormously.
The bridge-building itself is also far more compelling than I expected it to be. I never imagined I would become emotionally invested in anchor stones, centring and keystones, but here we are. Owen makes the physical process of building fascinating because it is never simply about engineering. Every structure William attempts reflects something about where he is in his life. He learns patience. He learns humility. He learns that strength does not necessarily come from adding more and more weight, and that sometimes the answer lies in understanding where the pressure needs to go.
There is something rather beautiful about that.
But this is not simply the story of one man learning how to build bridges.
The Welsh valley surrounding William is changing too. Coal begins to transform the landscape. Roads struggle beneath increasing traffic. Money brings opportunity, but it also brings power, ambition and people who are very interested in deciding exactly who should have that power. The world William knew as a child gradually becomes something different, and Owen handles that transition particularly well.
Rhys Price is a fascinating presence throughout. He is a man who believes very strongly in order — particularly when he is the person doing the ordering. His influence reaches into almost every part of valley life, and his need for control provides a very different kind of pressure from the river William is trying to understand.
Then there is Ewan.
Oh, Ewan.
There were occasions when I would happily have volunteered to help William find a particularly large stone for him.
The relationships between William, Elen, Mary, Myfanwy and the wider community give the novel much of its emotional weight. These characters grow alongside William, and their lives become increasingly complicated as childhood friendships, and frenemy, give way to adult loyalties, disappointments, responsibilities and choices. I particularly appreciated that the women are not merely standing around admiring William while he builds things. They have their own concerns, personalities and difficult decisions to make.
The setting deserves a mention as well because the landscape feels fundamental to the story. The river is never merely scenery. It feeds the valley, divides it, threatens it and challenges the people living beside it. William learns early that water does not tire. It will keep testing every weakness until it finds one.
That idea runs beautifully through the novel.
There is a wonderful sense of progression to 'When the Stones Held'. The little boy experimenting with structures becomes a young man earning money with his hands, and slowly we begin to understand how those apparently insignificant lessons are preparing him for something much larger.
And because Owen takes his time getting us there, William's achievements feel earned.
I also appreciated that William is never turned into some improbable eighteenth-century superhero. He doubts himself. He miscalculates. He gets things wrong. Other people question him, laugh at him and sometimes interfere when they would be considerably more useful standing somewhere else and keeping their hands to themselves.
Yet he keeps going.
That persistence is really the heart of this novel. William does not succeed because failure somehow stops happening to him. He succeeds because every failure teaches him something.
'When the Stones Held' is an engaging, thoughtful and beautifully grounded piece of historical fiction about craftsmanship, community, ambition and the extraordinary things that can grow from an ordinary person's determination to understand how something works.
I began the book knowing almost nothing about William Edwards.
I finished it wondering why on earth I had never heard more about him.
And I will never look at a stone bridge quite the same way again.

Belle Stanhope had plans. Good plans. Practical plans.
None of them involved Hudson Carver.
The florist with the crooked smile had become a distraction she neither wanted nor could avoid. Which was inconvenient, considering the Pretty River Inn and the upcoming bachelor auction left little room for distractions.
For years, Hudson had been content with the life he'd built beneath Christmas Mountain. His flower shop, his workshop, and the friends who had become family were more than he'd ever expected. Then he met Belle Stanhope.
As Christmas approaches, the carousel's calliope sings off-key, and the old magic he'd left behind stirs once more. The life he'd built and the life he wants are no longer the same.
In Forest Falls, wishes have a way of finding the people who need them most.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Oh look, a nice cosy Christmas romance (in which the local florist is hiding something, carousel music is behaving suspiciously, an old house appears to have opinions, and one woman is about to discover that denying you fancy someone becomes considerably harder when the entire town has already noticed).
The Midnight Carousel is funny, romantic, wonderfully Christmassy and just strange enough to make you wonder what on earth is actually going on in Forest Falls.
Belle Stanhope manages the Pretty River Inn, which means she is extremely good at organising other people.
Guests? Fine.
Staff? Fine.
Christmas events involving half the town? Absolutely fine.
Her own love life?
Less fine.
Particularly when Hudson Carver is involved.
Hudson is the local florist. He is handsome, kind, quiet and annoyingly good at making himself useful. He also seems to have perfected the art of looking at Belle as though he would very much like to say something and then deciding, at the last possible moment, that perhaps he won't.
This happens a lot.
Belle isn't much better.
She spends an impressive amount of time insisting that there is absolutely nothing going on while simultaneously noticing Hudson's eyes, hands, sweaters, forearms and general proximity.
She also becomes significantly less coordinated whenever he is nearby.
Fortunately, Hudson is very good at catching her.
Which is convenient.
Their romance is one of those deliciously frustrating ones where everybody knows what is happening except the two people actually involved.
Although, to be fair, I think they know too.
They are simply committed to making things difficult.
Hudson's approach is particularly impressive. At one point, Belle reminds him that he hid behind a poinsettia for two weeks.
He insists this was strategic.
Reader, it was not strategic.
Meanwhile, Forest Falls is busy being the sort of Christmas town that makes you want to pack a suitcase immediately.
There are snowy streets, twinkling lights, skating, Christmas trees, an old-fashioned inn, a carousel and enough festive charm to make even the most determined Christmas cynic reconsider their position.
Except something isn't quite right.
There are odd sounds.
Strange moments.
People who clearly know more than they are saying.
And a carousel that perhaps deserves slightly closer supervision.
Belle notices.
Hudson definitely notices.
Hudson would rather not discuss it.
This becomes increasingly inconvenient.
Thankfully, there are plenty of people around to make sure neither Belle nor Hudson is allowed to brood in peace.
Nana Iris was an absolute joy. She has reached that glorious stage of life where subtlety is entirely optional, particularly when it comes to Belle's romantic prospects.
JoJo isn't much better.
Aredhel, meanwhile, has the wonderful ability to make even the most peculiar situation sound as though everyone else is being unreasonable for finding it peculiar.
Then there is Mistletoe the cat, who quite rightly judges everybody.
But it was Belle and Hudson who kept me turning the pages.
Their relationship is funny, tender and painfully slow in exactly the right way. There are lingering looks, accidental touches, deliberate touches pretending to be accidental, walks through the snow and enough almost-moments to make you want to climb into the book and give them both a firm talking-to.
And then there is the bachelor auction.
I shall say very little about this because it deserves to be experienced without warning.
I will merely say that Belle discovers some interesting things about herself.
Common sense is not among them.
Beneath all the comedy and Christmas sparkle, though, there is a lovely story about loneliness, belonging and what it really means to find somewhere that feels like home.
That was the part I wasn't expecting to affect me quite as much as it did.
The Midnight Carousel made me laugh, made me impatient with two fictional people who desperately needed to sort themselves out, and made me wish Forest Falls existed.
Warm, magical, romantic and gloriously festive.
Five stars.
And I am still not accepting that hiding behind a poinsettia counts as a strategy.
***
If you are looking for an xmas fix, or know someone who would love to find a copy of Hanna's book under the tree you can pursches your copy over on The 'Zon!
***

A young woman answers a cry across the water and loses herself in the echo. Longstone Lighthouse, 1838. Grace Darling wakens to the howl o...